7 Mistakes When Shopping for Furniture at Consignment Shops

buying furniture

Shopping for consignment furniture can be an innovative and sustainable way to furnish your home. Not only do you get to save money, but you also get to give a new life to a pre-loved piece. However, finding the perfect item at a consignment store is not always easy. Many shoppers make mistakes that can lead to dissatisfaction and wasted time. To help you avoid these pitfalls, we’ve compiled a list of the seven most common mistakes people make when shopping for consignment furniture and how to avoid them.

1. Skipping the Research

Before you start shopping, you must know what you’re looking for in style, size, and budget. Take the time to measure your space, browse through interior design blogs, and create a list of needed furniture items. This way, you’ll have a clear idea of what you’re looking for and won’t be easily swayed by impulse purchases.

2. Ignoring Quality

While consignment furniture is often priced lower than brand-new pieces, it’s important to remember that not all used furniture is created equal. Refrain from assuming that it’s a good deal just because something is cheaper. Make sure to inspect each piece for signs of wear and tear, and consider the quality of the materials used. Solid wood furniture generally lasts longer than particleboard, and well-made upholstery is more comfortable than cheaply constructed alternatives.

3. Focusing Solely on Price

While it’s natural to want to save money, focusing solely on the price tag can lead to disappointment. Consider the overall value of each item – how well it fits your needs, whether it’s a high-quality piece, and how much you’ll use it – before deciding.

4. Not Asking for Additional Information

When shopping for consignment furniture, feel free to ask the store staff for more information about the piece you’re interested in. They may be able to provide additional details about the item’s history, materials used, or any repairs made. This information can help you make a more informed decision and ensure you get a piece that will last.

5. Overlooking Potential Red Flags

It’s essential to thoroughly inspect each piece of furniture before purchasing. Look for signs of damage, such as water stains, cracks, or loose joints. Additionally, check for any unpleasant smells, as these can be difficult to remove and may indicate mold or mildew issues. If you notice any red flags, it’s best to pass on the piece, as repairs can be costly and time-consuming.

6. Neglecting to Test the Furniture

Another common mistake is not testing the furniture before buying it. Sit on sofas and chairs, open and close drawers, and make sure any moving parts function smoothly. This will help you determine whether the piece is comfortable and functional and identify any potential issues that may not be immediately visible.

7. Failing to Negotiate

Finally, many shoppers miss out on potential savings by failing to negotiate. Consignment store prices are often negotiable; you can score a better deal by simply asking. Be polite and reasonable in your negotiations, and remember that the store owner is more likely to be flexible if they believe a sale is imminent.


By avoiding these common mistakes, you can increase your chances of finding the perfect consignment furniture for your home. Remember to do your research, prioritize quality over price, and don’t be afraid to negotiate. With a little patience and persistence, you can furnish your home with beautiful, sustainable pieces that will last for years to come.

Revamp your home with Collective Consignment’s wide range of quality consignment furniture in Naples, Florida! From living room sets to outdoor pieces, kitchen and dining essentials, and everything in between, we’ve got you covered. As one of the largest consignment shops in the area, we offer an extensive collection of home furnishings that are both affordable and stylish. Shop now!